Scott is Innocent

[JackIsBack]

This was his way of hoping Amber would not want to date him. Then he tried to convince her he did not want children beause he knew she did, but she still hounded him. Most women would not hang in a relationship like this. Why did Amber?

Yes.... what a dilemma Scott had (according to the prosecution)... he could have had a happy Laci or a moody Amber. He could raise his own child, or be stuck with Amber raising someone else's older child.

There is just no decision here... Laci wins Scott's heart hands down.... Amber was just a one nightstand that just happened at the wrong time for Scott and I bet he wished he could have shown more self control - he's paying a mighty big price right now for one lapse in judgement.

[Hipcheck]

Yes.... what a dilemma Scott had (according to the prosecution)... he could have had a happy Laci or a moody Amber. He could raise his own child, or be stuck with Amber raising someone else's older child.

Scott could have had a happy Laci if he chose not to cheat on her all the time. I believe Laci wasn't happy any more because of Scott's affairs and I believe she told him she wanted a divorce so he wouldn't be raising his child but paying big bucks for child support and since he didn't want to do that he murdered Laci like many husbands in that situation do.

And I never seen a moody Amber Frey.

[Moolah]

Other than Amber, Since they were married what other affairs did Scott have? I know they looked.. and there was some hints, but where are they and who are they?

Laci was happy, unhappy people do not have babies in a relationship.

[marlene]

Yes.... what a dilemma Scott had (according to the prosecution)... he could have had a happy Laci or a moody Amber. He could raise his own child, or be stuck with Amber raising someone else's older child.

Scott could have had a happy Laci if he chose not to cheat on her all the time. I believe Laci wasn't happy any more because of Scott's affairs and I believe she told him she wanted a divorce so he wouldn't be raising his child but paying big bucks for child support and since he didn't want to do that he murdered Laci like many husbands in that situation do.

And I never seen a moody Amber Frey.

Hipcheck, that is a totally ridiculous statement, "like many husbands in that situation do." The few notorious cases do not represent "many husbands."

Just when did she tell him she wanted a divorce?

[Hipcheck]

Other than Amber, Since they were married what other affairs did Scott have? I know they looked.. and there was some hints, but where are they and who are they?

Laci was happy, unhappy people do not have babies in a relationship.

Don't you remember Scott telling Shawn Sibley that he was tired of all the one night stands he had been having?

[marlene]

Other than Amber, Since they were married what other affairs did Scott have? I know they looked.. and there was some hints, but where are they and who are they?

Laci was happy, unhappy people do not have babies in a relationship.

Don't you remember Scott telling Shawn Sibley that he was tired of all the one night stands he had been having?

No, I don't remember that -- I was never privy to any conversation between Scott and Shawn. I do recall Shawn testifying that Scott told her that.

She must have been embarrassed to admit, in public to millions of people, including the man who was her fiance at the time of the conversation and her husband at the time of the trial, how she talked sex with Scott. It embarrassed the other men that were in the group. I wonder how many of those sex positions the fiance knew about.

Don't you think if Scott had been having a lot of one-night stands, the State would have paraded them before the Court? there was a rumor that Scott was having an affair with one of Laci's best friends -- that wouldn't do well to admit, though.

But that's beside the point as far as Laci's happiness. If she didn't know it, it wouldn't affect her happiness. If she knew it, and stayed, then she was consenting to it.

Of course there is the theory that Laci was waiting until after the holidays to reveal to her family that she was oh so close to ( ) that she was getting a divorce because she didn't want to spoil Christmas for them. How courageous of her. Well, then, why did she spring it on Scott before Christmas? Wouldn't she think that was going to spoil Christmas for everyone? After all, she had just accepted an invitation to go over to her Mom's the next night. And she had a family brunch planned for Christmas Day. Who would want a surly husband around during those times?

Besides, she put out a lot of bucks to buy his Christmas present -- if I found out about an affair, and decided to get a divorce, I'd take back the christmas gift before I sprung it on the husband.

And why woould all that go down the night of the 23rd? I mean, she brought Scott along to her prenatal appt that day. She was with Scott getting his haircut by her sister. What do you suppose happened to bring it all out on the night of the 23rd? You think maybe Amber showed up?

And if it all came to a head on the night of the 23rd, then Scott didn't buy the boat so he could use it to dump her body in the Bay. In fact, Scott didn't do any of the premeditation that the State accused him of if it only came to a head on the night of the 23rd.

[Moolah]

I am Tickled she is over on TAC helping me out. My brain sure isnt as good as hers to the facts, and I can use all the help I can get. Especially with the Nancy Graces of that board.

[JackIsBack]

And I never seen a moody Amber Frey.

Really? Amber always had a frown on... and people who are always frowning aren't very good company and aren't very good looking.

[JackIsBack]

And if it all came to a head on the night of the 23rd, then Scott didn't buy the boat so he could use it to dump her body in the Bay. In fact, Scott didn't do any of the premeditation that the State accused him of if it only came to a head on the night of the 23rd.

Yes... their (the states - prosecutions) story is just that... a nice fictional story and is more linked to their life experiences or thoughts then anything to do with Scott or the evidence in this case. It's absurd to think that Scott would purchase an asset like a boat for the sole purpose of killing his wife (or dumping the body)... it's almost as absurd as saying that Scott purchased his truck to transport his wife's body to the bay that day. Let's just pretend for a moment that the underlying theory is correct, it's more likely that Scott would just use assets he already owned to carry out this deed, especially larger ones. Buying a boat... with registration and the such, is a bit different then buying a shovel with cash to bury someone - and a Boat like the one Scott purchased, there is just no guarantee that it would do the job they're claiming Scott purchased it to do.

Want to get away with murder.... and you're planning it. Before you kill someone... dig the grave and make it deep... and place the pile of dirt right next to the hole for a quick infill... I mean this boat and weights thing is just all stupid nonsense and a stupid childish theory that an over imaginative police and prosector came up with while daydreaming one day.

[Hipcheck]

Really? Amber always had a frown on... and people who are always frowning aren't very good company and aren't very good looking.

Where did and how many times did you see this because I never did?